Factors Affecting Policy Implementation Green Island Project Tourism Essay

The award-winning Koh Samui tropical island Eden in Thailand carries testimonial for its natural appeal and alien nature which is spread over an expansive surface country. Koh Samui, which is besides the 3rd largest island in the Kingdom, is ranked among the most preferable tourer finishs, holding attracted 1,059,642 visitants in the twelvemonth 2007. The important rise in environmental concerns and the demand to conserve the island have nevertheless been evident and assorted stakeholders have made committednesss in aid in bettering the island. The Green Island Project-Koh Samui was initiated on 18th June 2007 as a three-phase preservation enterprise that would protect and continue the island ‘s environment and therefore heighten its long-run sustainability. The undertaking was designed as a 10-year enterprise. Three old ages down the line nevertheless, the promotion of the undertaking can non be considered a smooth enterprise. There are a figure of factors impacting on the success of policy in monitoring and implementing the macro and micro position of the undertaking. These include the political, societal and economic facets within the state and outside. In this paper, the factors impacting on policy success aimed at heightening environmental preservation in the island will be discussed ; with a position of set uping whether the refuse job could shortly be solved.

Statement and important jobs

A A A A A A Green Island has been identified as a site with the capacity of going one of the best tourer attractive forces sites if it is good developed and maintained to at least provide basic trade goods and a clean environment. Harmonizing to theA greenislandprojectA web site, more than 400 hotels offering cordial reception services at the international degree and with a capacity of 16, 000 suites have been developed. However, this Island is easy altering to a bare topographic point particularly with the deficiency of basic trade goods and deteriorating environmental conditions. For case, the populations populating in Green Island including visitants require about 18,000m3A to 22,000m3.A However, the purification processor can merely treat 5,754m3.A This means that the H2O available is non even plenty to fulfill a tierce of the population. In add-on, garbage installations are unequal to roll up all the refuse produced. Statisticss indicate that refuse produced bases at 120 dozenss per twenty-four hours ( Greenislandproject, 2011 ) . On the contrary, the capacity of the garbage installations is merely 130 dozenss a twenty-four hours and it could shortly be overwhelmed as tourer activity increases. This surely compromises hygiene factors and environmental preservation attempts which could drive away tourers. This is an happening that should be avoided extremely because Koh Samui relies to a great extent on touristry to obtain income.

A A A A A A Another job experienced in the country is increased traffic accidents. Policies aimed at work outing these insufficiencies have been developed. However, there is a broad disparity between what is written in the policy paper and what is go oning on the land. Degradation of the natural beauty and environmental jobs is a great menace to the people populating in the Island every bit good as its economic system. Green undertaking was started n June 2007 as a solution to the inauspicious effects of human actions with the purpose of reconstructing a green and clean environment. The chief intent is to strike a balance between environmental protection and touristry publicity.

A A A A A A Over the old ages, touristry has been found to be of economic value to states and persons populating in countries where tourists’A attractive force citations are located. Koh Samui ‘s Island is one of such countries. Global heating and environmental debasement pose a great menace to touristry citations. As the environment and its environing become hostile, animate beings and birds populating in it travel out in hunt for an alternate. Tourists are besides non ready to travel to countries that are polluted. Koh Samui ‘s Island is heading at that place if speedy and calculated actions are non taken to reconstruct her beauty.A A Green projectA is aimed at work outing these issues by coming up with ways in which adult male can stay environmental friendly.

A A A A A A Despite assorted actions to reconstruct the beauty of Koh Samui Island, the status is no better. Environmental pollution and deficiency of basic trade goods threatens her ability to stay attractive to tourist. The inquiry now is “ from both macro and micro positions, which factors affect the success of policy execution and monitoring inA Green Island Project: Koh Samui ‘s Thailand? ”

A A A A A A A batch of research has been conducted on policy execution and monitoring at the national and planetary degree. However, really small of this has been done in touristry sites such as Koh Samui Island in Thailand. Lack of such information makes it hard to understand the bing hinderances to policy execution and monitoring. Disregard of the importance of equal monitoring processs during and after policy execution in this country is clear both in theory and pattern. The research will be done through probe of Koh SamuiA Green island projectA as a instance survey through focal point groups and interviews. The proposal is divided to three parts including this debut. To get down with, the research inquiry is developed followed by literature reappraisal. The methodological analysis to be used in the probe is discussed in details.A A

Specific job to be addressed

A Waste direction at Kho Samui is raising great concern as the degree of waste production in the island additions. The Green Island Project must guarantee that waste direction is a precedence because it extremely threatens the scenic beauty in the island and could shortly impact on its ability to pull tourers in future. As celebrated earlier, the refuse aggregation systems are developing ; with a capacity of 130 dozenss per twenty-four hours merely. This is an undistinguished capacity given the fact that 120 dozenss of refuse is produced each twenty-four hours at the Island ( Greenislandproject, 2011 ) . There is need to pay more attending to the refuse aggregation facet in order to heighten the overall effectivity of the Green Island Project. More dedication towards this undertaking means that there should be efficient development of refuse aggregation methods development. The possibility of accomplishing this is nevertheless dependent on the ability of the concerned stakeholders to rush up the undertaking execution procedure. This is further influenced significantly by the environmental factors that are expected to catalyse or restrict the eventual accomplishment of aims. It is these factors impacting the execution of the Green Island Project that this paper seeks to set up, therefore specifying my survey.

Research Questions

The undermentioned inquiries will be answered in probe:

What are the relevant governments and non-governmental establishments making to better execution and monitoring of bing policies?

What is the action program to forestall deficient H2O resources and besides prevent impairment of bing H2O beginnings?

What is the solution to convey back the ecological balance in the country of the amendss in the seas and beaches?

Is there an effectual monitoring system for finding the success in policy execution?

Bash policy execution squad ‘s relevant accomplishments?

A A A Aims

To set up the factors that affect policy execution and monitoring.

To measure the execution of policies that address the accretion of refuse, chemical contaminations and other pollutants ;

To measure the execution of policies turn toing deficient H2O resources and impairment of bing H2O beginnings, ecological harm of seas and beaches, congestion, air and noise pollution, vehicle overloading and civilization impairment.

To place possible solutions to factors impacting policy execution and monitoring.

A Definitions

A A A A A A Policy execution harmonizing to Van Meter and Von Horn ( 1974 ) includes all action by an person or a group of people aimed at accomplishing set ends and aims. As declared inA kohsamuiholiday.com, 2010 “ Spearheaded by the KohSamui Tourism Promotion Association, the Thai Hotels Association Southeastern Chapter and Samui Spa Association, with the full support of provincial governments, the Ministry of Tourism and Sports ( MOTS ) and the Tourism Authority of Thailand ( TAT ) , the “ Green Island Project – KohSamui ” was officially launched on June 18, 2007. This three-phase preservation enterprise purposes to protect and continue the environment in order to guarantee long-run sustainability. ”

A A A A A A As stated inA samuivillasandhomes.com, 2010 “ Waste direction is the aggregation, transporting, processing, recycling or disposal of waste stuffs ” . Waste stuffs refer to stuffs produced by human activity and pull offing the waste refers to the procedure of cut downing the stuffs consequence on the environment. Our end is to hold zero net waste from our central offices edifice in five old ages. ”

A A A A A A As stated inA samuivillasandhomes.com, 2010 “ there is usage of Effective Microorganisms ( EM ) in the care of SVH-PVH offices and Villas. “ A EM is the name of a specific group of of course happening good micro-organisms with an astonishing ability to resuscitate, reconstruct and continue ”

A A A A A A As stated in theA tatnews.org, 2010 “ The Tourism Authority of Thailand ( TAT ) and the Thai touristry industry are jointly prosecuting ‘green initiatives’A in an attempt to keep the delicate balance between touristry publicity and environmental protection to guarantee long-run sustainability. “ A

Justification: Benefits of the survey

A A A A A A Poor policy execution and monitoring is a major hinderance to realisation of set organisational ends and aims. For Koh Samui, neglecting to accomplish her end of transforming her environment to a tourer friendly environment would non merely average loss of tourers but besides loss of a beginning of economic value of touristry and a beginning of support for those life in the country. This is a really of import research particularly at a clip when communities have become environmental witting and attempts have been directed towards cut downing planetary heating ( Wormer & A ; Besthorn, 2010 ) . It will be good to the community members as it will place what the community should make to bask a clean and wellness environment. This research will do it easy for the authorities will to place the agencies to guarantee saneness is restored in keeping a clean environment. Last, it will be utile to future research workers in placing bing spreads and countries of cardinal involvement.

Restrictions of the research

A A A A The research may neglect to accomplish fullness as much traveling is required and available resources are non plenty to guarantee that this is achieved. In add-on, there has been less research done on this country doing it difficult to formalize collected every bit good as the small available secondary informations. Seasonality of tourer visits besides poses a great menace as general decisions drawn after the research is conducted at this clip may non be applicable for all seasons. It is besides noteworthy that the alterations in the environment following the execution of the Green Island Project may non be easy quantified. This can be explained by the usage of ‘increased ‘ , ‘reduced ‘ , ‘elevated ‘ and ‘deteriorated ‘ among others in showing the alterations in Koh Samui as opposed to holding numerical statistics.

Literature reappraisal

Policy Implementation and touristry policy

Policy execution harmonizing to Van Meter and Von Horn ( 1974 ) includes all action by an person or a group of people aimed at accomplishing set ends and aims. Specific action aimed at guaranting that policy aims are achieved should be designed and acted upon. Harmonizing to the Thai touristry, the traveling ‘green’A plan spurred the creative activity of seven green enterprises. The enterprises had been crafted as guidelines in the development stage and existent constitution of a database which would garner all pertinent information of touristry operators in the island with respect to the services they offer vis-a-vis conserving the environment. Policies aimed at environmental saving have been set by the province. Tourism policies are aimed at advancing touristry activities ( Yuan et al, 2006 ) .

Networking theory

Networking becomes a really easy manner of act uponing people to move in a given mode. Policy execution to some extent depends on available societal webs. It is through these webs that norms are shared and information passed. Involving all stakeholders is necessary to understand their position refering the factors impacting policy execution and monitoring. In this instance, stakeholders include touristry operators who interact with the environment on day-to-day footing and need developing on how to equilibrate their operations and environmental saving ( Yuan et Al, 2006 ) . The province proctors and gives directs on necessary stairss to be undertaken in guaranting sustainability in touristry operations. Local community form a really of import portion of the stakeholders as their credence and support of policy execution greatly determines its success.

Another of import group is the media. It is involved in distributing intelligence on the importance of environmental saving every bit good as advertisement sites which are environmental friendly therefore pulling tourers. The media is a really influential tool in networking. To look into factors impacting the success of policy execution and monitoring, media can non be ignored. The effectivity of media groups on distributing information on environmental saving must hence be investigated to find if there is any escape or mistake in the manner this is done.

Social capital theory

Existing societal dealingss determine how different stakeholders cooperate to achieve a common end for the good of all ( Wasko & A ; Faraj, 2005 ) . Harmonizing to societal capital theory, success of policy execution is sometimes dependent on sensed capital benefits. As a consequence, from the community angle, this research will look at factors impacting success of policy execution and monitoring in relation to comprehend economic benefit or loss at single and community degree. Wasko and Faraj ( 2005 ) explain that societal capital additions productiveness in the same mode as human and physical capital. Policy execution should therefore focal point on behavioural alteration to guarantee that community members adopt behaviours aimed at environmental saving ( Newell et al, 2004 ) .A Harmonizing to Preece ( 2002 ) , the willingness of citizens to take part in such enterprises determines the degree of success achieved. Social capital therefore encompasses webs and norms directing people to move in a given mode for common benefits which may be economic or non-economic ( Wasko & A ; Faraj, 2005 ) .

Emerging issues in the Green Island Project -Koh Samui

The recent planetary economic crisis is one of the most important factors that have affected the Green Island Project. The world-wide recession non merely led to a decrease in the figure of tourers but besides impacted on the island ‘s budget. Harmonizing to Ramnate Jaikwang, the city manager of Koh Samui, the chief gross earner which is touristry suffered a great blow following the planetary fiscal crisis due to a reduced figure of visitants ( Roxas, 2011 ) .

The political agitation that was witnessed in Thai capital and environing countries was a major menace to touristry and this affected the island in a important mode. The civil agitation which occurred in 2010 involved anti-government protestors and soldiers in Bangkok ; which left about 24 people dead and 800 injured ( CBS News, 2010 ) . While the protests were expected to lessen, it was evident that the impact on touristry was impossible. This was an unfortunate happening, given the high trust of Thailand on touristry. Visitors were loath to see the state therefore cut downing Koh Samui ‘s gross. Consequently, the aims of keeping a clean, green and safe Samui were curtailed to a great extent. The Koh Samui city manager nevertheless indicated that get downing the twelvemonth 2011, important developments would be recorded in the island in a command to maintain it clean ( Roxas, 2011 ) .

Methods of supervising alteration impacts

A A A A A A Monitoring is an built-in portion of the alteration procedure without which success would merely stay a dream.A An adaptative direction rhythm where monitoring is done has been found to be really effectual in monitoring policy execution and placing of import alterations necessary to accomplish success ( Angelsen, 2008 ) . As a consequence, the effectivity of the monitoring system will be evaluated.

Conceptual frame work

A A A A A A The developed conceptual model identifies immediate determiners of successful policy execution and monitoring as concerted actions by community members, efficiency of supervising systems and support from authorities. These are nevertheless influenced by handiness of effectual communicating systems and cooperation of Government and non-governmental bureaus. The root causes of failure or success are the bing proficient, societal and political environment. For case, presence of struggle finally consequences to failure in policy execution and monitoring.A The societal networking theory will be utilized as the conceptual model for this survey.

The societal networking theory

The popularity of the networking theory in societal scientific disciplines has been evident since the 1970s largely in the transmittal of intelligence and rumours and diffusion of inventions. It has besides been significantly used in analyzing the spread of diseases and behaviours related to wellness. Social networking concerns the construction of relationships between societal entities, including persons, organisations, groups, national provinces scholarly publications and web sites ( Scott, 2009 ) . Networking is considered an easy manner to act upon people in moving in a specific mode. Notably, the usage of networking in the execution of the plan will act upon its success to a important degree. This is because networks provide an avenue for communicating and sharing of of import information and norms. By associating all the stakeholders, coordination is made easy and hence the execution of a peculiar aim is bound to be extremely efficient ( Scott, 2009 ) . Furthermore, societal webs allow stakeholders to larn from each other and to work together through guaranting that they can reach each other at any given clip.

The conceptual model below will be utilized in the research.A

The conceptual model represents state of affairs in which there is a important degree of coaction between the authorities, non-governmental organic structures, the local concern community, community members and the media in accomplishing the aims of the Green Island Project. Since all these stakeholders are direct participants in heightening the success of the undertaking, there is demand for effectual communicating and networking in order to heighten coordination. Through representatives, the non-governmental organic structures, local concerns and the community will have and direct information collected from an organized web amongst themselves as indicated in the diagram. Besides direct communicating between the assorted stakeholders, media at the Centre of the web to ease communicating from the assorted stakeholders.

Research design

Descriptive research design will be applied in roll uping the information for this survey. This is owed to the fact that the sample population is rather big and the demand to analyze the natural behaviour of samples. The research is aimed at look intoing the relationship that exists between different variables and descriptive research is really utile when look intoing societal factors. Both qualitative and quantitative information was collected to guarantee fullness in the survey. Children will non be involved in the research due to the high possibility of kids giving subjective instead than nonsubjective information. Qualitative information collected will so be coded so as to heighten production of scientific consequences after analysis.


Qualitative surveies are frequently characterized by proof issues because of the nature of the design. Use of secondary beginnings to roll up informations in peculiar has dependability issues as it is normally hard for the research worker to place mistakes that might hold occurred particularly during aggregation of information and information. To turn to this issue, the research worker intends to utilize multiple positions in proof. This will affect a comparing of findings by different research workers on the same topic. In this instance, past researches on policy execution and monitoring will be used. The lone challenge will be acquiring information on policy execution for this peculiar Island. This scheme has been recommended in qualitative surveies where triangulation can non be carried out so as to increase the cogency and dependability of the findings.


A A A A A A The sample will be determined through random sampling of tourer sites and purposive sampling employees working at that place, policy implementers and tourers. These will be determined by first finding the sites in the Island. Purposive sampling was applied as the research focused on policy execution and monitoring. Information will besides be collected from governmental studies and published studies for intent of proof. Children will non be interviewed as they will be considered incapable of giving sound information. The survey will to a greater extent rely on first manus informations.

Description of the survey population

A A A A A A The survey population will include employees in tourer sites, policy implementers and tourer in touristry attractive force sites in Koh Samui Island. The inclusion of persons will non be based on race, nationality or societal position. This means that the survey population will include people from different races and nationalities as these may be a conducive factor to failure in policy execution and monitoring. The usage of an indifferent population will guarantee that there is equal information to reflect the existent state of affairs in the state.

Data aggregation Instruments

A A A A A A Questionnaires and interview agendas will be applied to roll up informations. Questionnaires will be mailed to participant who will non be available during group treatments. The usage of questionnaires has an advantage in that more truth is expected because the questionnaire helps in obtaining more elaborate information.

Datas Analysis

A A A A A A After all necessary information is gathered, it will be analyzed through the application of SPSS. This enhanced truth in describing. Qualitative information will be coded and so analyzed utilizing this package. The information will be professionally analyzed to better truth and precision.A A

Case comparing: Phuket rubbish direction

Siam in the recent yesteryear has recorded a important degree of environmental direction issues. Phuket Island is extremely affected by the refuse job which has about threatened its touristry potency to a important degree. In this respect, attempts have been taken to guarantee that refuse does non present a challenge to the possible growing of touristry in the state. The Phuket Trash Management Committee in concurrence with the Phuket City Municipality is working with the authorities to guarantee that the rubbish is efficaciously managed ( Phuket Index, 2011 ) . Presently, the Phuket Trash Management Committee is in the procedure of building the 2nd incinerator. The undertaking is being funded by the authorities through the Thai Khem Khang undertaking ( or Thai Strength ) . This is an economic stimulation disbursement plan intended to help the state ‘s economic recovery. The building will affect the building of an asphalt route taking to the landfill country and incinerator and besides install high metal light stations, 12 CCTV sets and rubbish vehicle rinsing country. The work is expected to be completed by December 2011.

Similar to the refuse job in Koh Samui, Koh Phuket is greatly affected and there is no uncertainty that the refuse is overpowering. The island presently generates 500 dozenss of rubbish, yet the bing incinerator can merely manage 250 dozenss a twenty-four hours ( Phuket Index, 2011 ) . This is a similar state of affairs to Koh Samui ‘s job where merely 130 dozenss of waste produced can be accommodated by the refusal system. The job at Koh Phuket is nevertheless more exaggerated, given that the sum of rubbish is much higher than in Samui. Another difference is that Koh Phuket ‘s refuse aggregation aims seem to be more solid and effectual. Besides building the incinerator, this is accompanied by the building of a route, illuming, vehicle rinsing countries, vehicles and Ultra-Low-Volume ( ULV ) sprayers ( Phuket Index, 2011 ) . Further, there are programs of utilizing the waste in the coevals of electricity energy from organic waste. Koh Puhket continues to confront refuse menace but besides promises high degree of development, largely in the building of disposal installations.